The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has vacated a preliminary injunction that restricted federal agents from using tear gas, pepper balls, and other nonlethal munitions near the Portland Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility unless a specific individual posed an imminent threat of physical harm. In Dickinson v. Trump, No. 26-1609 (9th Cir. Nov. 10, 2026), the panel also vacated a provisional class certification covering all persons who have, desire to, or will nonviolently protest or report on Department of Homeland Security activities at the facility. The decision confirms that officers may employ nonlethal force to clear a crowd and restore order when there exists a clear and present danger of riot, disorder, interference with traffic, or other immediate threat to public safety, peace, or order. This ruling supplies useful guidance for California peace officers confronting claims that force used amid mixed protests constitutes First Amendment retaliation.
Between June 2025 and February 2026 at least 150 protests occurred at the
Portland facility. While many participants engaged in protected expression,
others trespassed on federal property, blocked driveways, vandalized
structures, hurled objects at officers, and attempted to penetrate the
building. Five named plaintiffs, identified as peaceful protesters and
independent journalists, were struck by pepper balls or exposed to tear gas or
pepper spray while present near those events. They alleged that agents targeted
them pursuant to an unwritten Department of Homeland Security policy of
retaliating against First Amendment activity. After an evidentiary hearing, the
district court entered a broad preliminary injunction prohibiting munitions
unless the specific target posed an imminent threat of physical harm,
restricting pepper spray, barring shots to the head, neck, or torso unless
deadly force was justified, and directing redesign of agent uniforms. The court
also provisionally certified a class of all people who have, desire to, or will
nonviolently protest or report on DHS activities at the site.
The panel, in an opinion by Judge Lee, held that the plaintiffs had not
shown a likelihood of success on the merits of their retaliation claim. The
district court erred by assuming that nonlethal munitions may be used only in
response to an imminent threat of physical harm. Under Puente v. City of
Phoenix, 123 F.4th 1035 (9th Cir. 2024), officers may disperse a protesting
crowd when there are objectively reasonable grounds to conclude that a clear
and present danger of riot, disorder, interference with traffic, or other
immediate threat to public safety, peace, or order exists, judged by the tenor
of the demonstration as a whole. The plaintiffs were collateral casualties of
efforts to quell disorder rather than intentional targets. No evidence
established an unwritten retaliation policy, and written DHS policy expressly
prohibits targeting individuals for free speech. The injunction was overbroad
because it extended relief to nonparties contrary to Trump v. CASA, Inc., 606
U.S. 831 (2025), imposed an incorrect legal standard, and ordered uniform
redesign beyond judicial authority. Class certification failed for lack of
commonality, as the class mixed peaceful protesters with those engaged in
unlawful activity and retaliation claims turn on individualized facts, and for
failure to satisfy the indivisible remedy requirement of Rule 23(b)(2).
Judge de Alba concurred in part and dissented in part. She would have upheld
the prohibition against firing munitions at the head, neck, or torso unless
deadly force was justified and would have affirmed class certification.
The decision benefits California public safety unions by clarifying that
officers need not wait for an imminent physical threat before employing
nonlethal tools when the overall tenor of a demonstration presents a clear and
present danger of disorder. Agencies should document the specific conditions
justifying each dispersal, including trespass, blocked access, vandalism, and
assaults, along with warnings and the crowd response. Written anti-retaliation
policies, consistent training, and preserved video, munitions logs, and after
action reports help defeat claims that force targeted protected speech. Courts
remain unlikely to sustain broad protester classes or to micromanage
operational details such as uniform design. The partial dissent highlights the
head, neck, and torso restriction as the narrow limit most likely to draw
further judicial attention. Further review remains possible, so public safety
professionals should confirm the decision’s status before relying on it.



